Dossier One / Legal opinion
Is the criminal case against your client political?
A signed opinion that answers one question with reasons and sources. Compliance teams use it when a database shows a criminal case or a wanted notice from Russia, Belarus or Central Asia and the client says it is persecution.
Why a database cannot answer this
A screening tool records that a case exists. It does not record that the “crime” was a social media post about the war, a donation to an anti-corruption fund, or a missed “foreign agent” filing. Without that, the bank sees a wanted person, closes the account, and may lose a client who is in fact a refugee.
The opposite error is as costly: treating a genuine fraud or violent crime as persecution because the client says so. The opinion is written to stand up to both readings.
What we examine
- The article of the criminal code and the conduct actually alleged
- Whether that conduct would be a crime in the EU (dual criminality)
- The timing of the case against the person’s journalism, activism, business dispute or emigration
- Procedural signs: trial in absentia, closed hearings, refused counsel, pressure on relatives
- How courts and human rights bodies have assessed the same article and similar cases
The standards we apply
- Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly, Resolution 1900 (2012) on the definition of a political prisoner
- European Convention on Human Rights, Article 18, and the Strasbourg case law applying it
- Constitution of INTERPOL, Article 3: no activity of a political, military, religious or racial character
Articles we see most often
Russia · Belarus- RU 207.3
- “Knowingly false information” about the armed forces
- RU 280.3
- “Discrediting” the armed forces
- RU 282.3
- “Financing extremist activity”, used against donors to banned organisations
- RU 284.1
- Participation in an “undesirable” organisation
- RU 330.1
- Evading “foreign agent” obligations
- BY 342
- Group actions grossly violating public order, used after the 2020 protests
- BY 361-1
- Creating or joining an “extremist formation”
An article on this list is a reason to look closer, not a conclusion. The same articles are sometimes used in cases with real criminal conduct.
Who signs
A lawyer with experience of criminal and extradition cases from the region. name and bar admission to be added
Language
English, Spanish or Russian. Quoted Russian sources are translated in the text.
Independence
We do not represent the subject in the criminal case. If the subject commissions the opinion, it says so on the first page.
Turnaround and price
5–10 business days. Quoted per case within one business day.
Other questions an opinion can answer
One question per opinion keeps it short enough to be read and specific enough to be relied on.
Reg. (EU) 833/2014 art. 5b
Deposit restriction
Does the €100,000 deposit prohibition apply to this client, given nationality, residence and permits?
Reg. (EU) 269/2014
Ownership and control
Is a company owned or controlled by a listed person, directly or through others?
Foreign judgment
Weight of a conviction
What a conviction in absentia from the region means for the risk assessment.
Tell us about the person and your question. Within one business day you receive the scope, the price and the date.
We need the full name, date of birth and citizenship, and if available a passport or taxpayer number. No obligation; we check for conflicts of interest before accepting any engagement.